 Cynthia Ann Stewart | Wife | | 26 JUN 1817 | | |
 Isaiah H. Stewart | Father-in-law | Clark County, Kentucky | 24 FEB 1791 | Indiana | 20 NOV 1868 |
| Jane McCullough | Mother-in-law | Clark County, Kentucky | 1792 | Kentucky | 1818 |
| John H. Stewart | Brother-in-law | Montgomery County, Kentucky | 20 APR 1813 | Jefferson Country, Indiana | 25 DEC 1877 |
| David Stewart | Brother-in-law | | 22 MAY 1815 | Brushy Fork Church Cemetary, Indiana | 13 MAR 1896 |
| William Stewart | Brother-in-law | | 25 JUN 1819 | | |
| Mary J. Stewart | Sister-in-law | | 31 DEC 1821 | | |
| James M. Stewart | Brother-in-law | | 10 FEB 1824 | | |
| George W. H. Stewart | Brother-in-law | | 08 NOV 1826 | | |
| Levi W. Stewart | Brother-in-law | | 15 OCT 1828 | | |
| Edith L. Stewart | Sister-in-law | | 17 OCT 1830 | | |
| Robert F. Stewart | Brother-in-law | | 20 OCT 1832 | | |
| Eliza B. Stewart | Sister-in-law | | 18 MAR 1835 | | |
| Samuel H. Stewart | Brother-in-law | | 09 JAN 1838 | Canaan Methodist Church Cemetary, Indiana | 1912 |
| Benjamin Stewart | Brother-in-law | | 29 JAN 1840 | | |
| Joseph D. Stewart | Brother-in-law | | 10 SEP 1841 | | |
| Lewis Conner Stewart | Nephew-in-law | Indiana | 30 APR 1835 | Indiana | 11 APR 1895 |
| Amanda Stewart | Niece-in-law | | 1842 | | |
| Jane Stewart | Niece-in-law | | 1845 | | |
| Edith E. Stewart | Niece-in-law | | 1847 | | |
| Elizabeth Stewart | Niece-in-law | | 15 SEP 1849 | | |
| John F. Stewart | Nephew-in-law | Jefferson County, Indiana | 1853 | | |
| James J. Stewart | Nephew-in-law | Jefferson County, Indiana | 22 JAN 1855 | Jefferson County, Indiana | 11 MAY 1925 |
| Edwin R. Stewart | Nephew-in-law | Jefferson County, Indiana | 1860 | | |
| Robert B. Stewart | Nephew-in-law | Jefferson County, Indiana | 1862 | | 1904 |
| B. R. Stewart | Grandnephew-in-law | | | | |
| Charles V. Stewart | Grandnephew-in-law | | | | |
| Della Francis Stewart | Grandniece-in-law | Canaan, Jefferson County, Indiana | | | 15 SEP 1959 |
| Hazel Stewart | Grandniece-in-law | | | | |
| Mary Ellen Stewart | Grandniece-in-law | | | | |
| Unknown Stewart | Grandniece-in-law | | | | |
| Sarah A. Stewart | Grandniece-in-law | Indiana | 1861 | | |
| Lorenzo C. Landslott | Grandnephew-in-law | Indiana | 1865 | | |
| Amanda Stewart | Grandniece-in-law | Indiana | 1868 | | |
| David Marshall Stewart | Grandnephew-in-law | Indiana | 19 APR 1871 | Iowa | 04 JUL 1954 |
| Irene Stewart | Grandniece-in-law | Indiana | 1872 | Indiana | 1875 |
| Robert Effner Stewart | Grandnephew-in-law | Indiana | 20 SEP 1878 | | |
| May Stewart | Grandniece-in-law | Indiana | 1879 | | |
| William L. Stewart | Grandnephew-in-law | Indiana | 1884 | | |
| Henrietta | Grandmother-in-law | Scotland | | | |
| David Stewart | Grandfather-in-law | New Jersey | 1740 | Montgomery County, Kentucky | 1805 |
| John McCullough | Grandfather-in-law | Pennsylvania | JAN 1755 | Mercer County, Kentucky | 15 JUN 1823 |
| Constant Keziah Jones | Grandmother-in-law | North Carolina | 1770 | Ripley County, Indiana | 1855 |
| Elizabeth Unknown | Great grandmother-in-law | | | | |
| Elizabeth Unknown | Great grandmother-in-law | | | | |
| George | Great grandfather-in-law | | | | |
| John Charles Stewart | Great grandfather-in-law | | | | |
| Keziah Unknown | Great grandmother-in-law | | | | |
| John Jones | Great grandfather-in-law | | 1730 | | |
| James McCullough | Great grandfather-in-law | North Carolina | 1734 | | DEC 1757 |
| Elizabeth McCullough | Second great grandmother-in-law | North Carolina | | | |
| Stewart | Second great grandfather-in-law | | | | |
| James McCullough | Second great grandfather-in-law | North Carolina | 1705 | | DEC 1757 |
| Female Unnown | Third great grandmother-in-law | | | | |
| Samuel McCullough | Third great grandfather-in-law | North Carolina | 1680 | | DEC 1756 |